Scholarship
Articulating and defending what has been handed down, and applying to current situations.
Genus
| Government | Relation and summary |
|---|
| Self | P+C Think God’s thoughts after Him; seek out what is concelaed; excel |
| in calling | |
| Family | C Raise, fund and send scholars; dominate creation |
| Church | P+R Guard doctrine; train ministers; refute error |
| Civil | R Protect inquiry; punish blasphemy |
Fields
Divided by: Subject of inquiry.
| Field | Summary | Differentiation |
|---|
| Economics and social science | How households and nations prosper | None yet |
| History | Remembering the works of God | Family: Household memory: genealogies, family, national history. |
| Jurisprudence | The study of God’s law and its application | Church: Teaches the law’s abiding use (WCF 19). Civil: Magistrates should be students of God’s law (Deut 17:18-20). |
| Languages and letters | Biblical languages, Latin, rhetoric, translation | None yet |
| Natural science | Searching out God’s works; use the creation to alleviate | |
| human needs and suffering | None yet | |
| Philosophy | Reasoning from the fear of the Lord | None yet |
| Theology | Queen of the sciences; governs other fields | Church: Doctrine is the church’s to uphold and protect. |
Subsections of Scholarship
Self
Self in Scholarship
| Relation | Summary |
|---|
| P+C (Principal + Constitutive) | Think God’s thoughts after Him; seek out what is concelaed; excell in vocation |
End
Pursue understanding in a calling of study, taking every thought captive.
Means
Direct
Instrumental
- Faculty and fellows
- Learned societies
Agent
The scholar
Norm
- Prov 25:2
- 2 Cor 10:5
- Acts 17:11
Boundary
The scholar remains under Scripture, his church and his household duties.
Failure modes
Neglect: Anti-intellectualism.
Usurpation: Autonomous reason; the pride of knowledge (1 Cor 8:1).
Love the Lord with all your mind.
Family
Family in Scholarship
| Relation | Summary |
|---|
| C (Constitutive) | Raise, fund and send scholars |
End
Raise and fund scholars; keep a household culture of learning.
Means
Direct
- Household libraries
- Patronage
Instrumental
- Colleges
- Research institutes
- Think tanks
- Journals
Agent
Head of household and members
Norm
Boundary
Directs an academy through its charter and trustees, not by interfering in its daily rule.
Failure modes
Neglect: Sons sent into debt for credentials from hostile institutions.
Usurpation: College treated as a status purchase.
Families ought to support and pursue higher learning as time and gifts allow.
Church
Church in Scholarship
| Relation | Summary |
|---|
| P+R (Principal + Regulative) | Guard doctrine; train ministers; refute error |
End
Guard doctrine, train ministers, and test scholarship by Scripture.
Means
Direct
- Confessional standards
- Ordination examinations
Instrumental
- Seminaries under church oversight
Agent
Presbyteries and elders
Norm
- 2 Tim 2:2
- Titus 1:9
- 1 Tim 3:15
Boundary
Does not dictate method in disciplines beyond what Scripture teaches.
Failure modes
Neglect: Seminaries independent of any church, drifting doctrinally.
Usurpation: Clerical control of all inquiry.
The Church should be directly and indirectly instrumental in the defense and
pursuit of higher learning, specifically with regard to the deeper understanding
and defense of the faith.
Civil
Civil in Scholarship
| Relation | Summary |
|---|
| R (Regulative) | Protect inquiry; punish blasphemy |
End
Promote the common good, protect liberty of inquiry within God’s law; punish fraud and blasphemy.
Means
Direct
Instrumental
None.
Agent
Magistrates
Norm
Boundary
No funding or accreditation.
Failure modes
Neglect: Ungodly and destructive heresies or idolatry permitted to be publicly promoted.
Usurpation: State accreditation and research funding that usurps inquiry.
Magistrates ought to protect the pursuit of knowledge, without giving license
to idolatry or blasphemy.